1958

Academy winnerGigi poster

Gigi

Composite 63.2

vs
Should have wonVertigo poster

Vertigo

Composite 80.96

The Academy's ballot

Your #1 was Vertigo (#1).

The full slate

#1
Vertigo poster

Vertigo (1958)

⭐ Top-rated🏛️ All-time great💰 Box office #5

Composite 80.96

Dir. Alfred Hitchcock · James Stewart · Kim Novak · Barbara Bel Geddes · Tom Helmore

IMDb 8.2 (459,093 votes) · TMDB 8.1

A retired San Francisco detective suffering from acrophobia investigates the strange activities of an old friend's wife, all the while becoming dangerously obsessed with her.

details ↗
#2
Touch of Evil poster

Touch of Evil (1958)

⭐ Top-rated

Composite 76.33

Dir. Orson Welles · Charlton Heston · Janet Leigh · Orson Welles · Joseph Calleia

IMDb 7.9 (114,888 votes) · TMDB 7.742

A border-town bombing draws Mexican investigator Miguel Vargas into a corruption-ridden police investigation led by crooked captain Hank Quinlan, setting off a deadly struggle over power, justice, and truth.

details ↗
#3
The Hidden Fortress poster

The Hidden Fortress (1958)

⭐ Top-rated

Composite 75.42

Dir. Akira Kurosawa · Toshirō Mifune · Minoru Chiaki · Kamatari Fujiwara · Misa Uehara

IMDb 8.0 (45,940 votes) · TMDB 8.0

In feudal Japan, during a bloody war between clans, two cowardly and greedy peasants, soldiers of a defeated army, stumble upon a mysterious man who guides them to a fortress hidden in the mountains.

details ↗
#4
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof poster

Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (1958)

🎬 Nominee⭐ Top-rated💰 Box office #2

Composite 74.36

Dir. Richard Brooks · Paul Newman · Elizabeth Taylor · Burl Ives · Judith Anderson

IMDb 7.9 (57,089 votes) · TMDB 7.6

An alcoholic ex-football player drinks his days away, having failed to come to terms with his sexuality and his real feelings for his football buddy who died after an ambiguous accident. His wife is crucified by her desperation to make him desire her: but he resists the affections of his wife. His reunion with his father—who is dying of cancer—jogs a host of memories and revelations for both father and son.

details ↗
#5
Elevator to the Gallows poster

Elevator to the Gallows (1958)

⭐ Top-rated

Composite 72.69

Dir. Louis Malle · Jeanne Moreau · Maurice Ronet · Georges Poujouly · Yori Bertin

IMDb 7.9 (31,812 votes) · TMDB 7.601

A self-assured businessman murders his employer, husband of his mistress, which unintentionally provokes an ill-fated chain of events.

details ↗
#6
The Big Country poster

The Big Country (1958)

⭐ Top-rated💰 Box office #7

Composite 71.87

Dir. William Wyler · Gregory Peck · Jean Simmons · Carroll Baker · Charlton Heston

IMDb 7.9 (24,327 votes) · TMDB 7.6

Retired wealthy sea captain Jim McKay arrives in the Old West, where he becomes embroiled in a feud between his future father-in-law, Major Terrill, and the rough and lawless Hannasseys over a valuable patch of land.

details ↗
#7
A Night to Remember poster

A Night to Remember (1958)

⭐ Top-rated

Composite 71.47

Dir. Roy Ward Baker · Kenneth More · Ronald Allen · Robert Ayres · Honor Blackman

IMDb 7.9 (19,370 votes) · TMDB 7.7

The sinking of the Titanic is presented in a highly realistic fashion in this tense British drama. The disaster is portrayed largely from the perspective of the ocean liner's second officer, Charles Lightoller. Despite numerous warnings about ice, the ship sails on, with Capt. Edward John Smith keeping it going at a steady clip. When the doomed vessel finally hits an iceberg, the crew and passengers discover that they lack enough lifeboats, and tragedy follows.

details ↗
#8
Big Deal on Madonna Street poster

Big Deal on Madonna Street (1958)

⭐ Top-rated

Composite 71.44

Dir. Mario Monicelli · Vittorio Gassman · Renato Salvatori · Memmo Carotenuto · Rossana Rory

IMDb 7.9 (12,871 votes) · TMDB 8.087

Best friends Peppe and Mario are thieves, but they're not very good at it. Still, Peppe thinks that he's finally devised a master heist that will make them rich. With the help of some fellow criminals, he plans to dig a tunnel from a rented apartment to the pawnshop next door, where they can rob the safe. But his plan is far from foolproof, and the fact that no one in the group has any experience digging tunnels proves to be the least of their problems.

details ↗
#9
My Uncle poster

My Uncle (1958)

⭐ Top-rated

Composite 70.29

Dir. Jacques Tati · Jacques Tati · Jean-Pierre Zola · Adrienne Servantie · Lucien Frégis

IMDb 7.6 (24,909 votes) · TMDB 7.4

Genial, bumbling Monsieur Hulot loves his top-floor apartment in a grimy corner of the city, and cannot fathom why his sister's family has moved to the suburbs. Their house is an ultra-modern nightmare, which Hulot only visits for the sake of stealing away his rambunctious young nephew. Hulot's sister, however, wants to win him over to her new way of life, and conspires to set him up with a wife and job.

details ↗
#10
Ashes and Diamonds poster

Ashes and Diamonds (1958)

⭐ Top-rated

Composite 69.3

Dir. Andrzej Wajda · Zbigniew Cybulski · Ewa Krzyżewska · Wacław Zastrzeżynski · Adam Pawlikowski

IMDb 7.7 (15,045 votes) · TMDB 7.4

A young academy soldier, Maciek Chelmicki, is ordered to shoot the secretary of the KW PPR. A coincidence causes him to kill someone else. Meeting face to face with his victim, he gets a shock. He faces the necessity of repeating the assassination. He meets Krystyna, a girl working as a barmaid in the restaurant of the "Monopol" hotel. His affection for her makes him even more aware of the senselessness of killing at the end of the war. Loyalty to the oath he took, and thus the obligation to obey the order, tips the scales.

details ↗
#11
Dracula poster

Dracula (1958)

⭐ Top-rated💰 Box office #8

Composite 68.94

Dir. Terence Fisher · Peter Cushing · Christopher Lee · Michael Gough · Melissa Stribling

IMDb 7.2 (29,977 votes) · TMDB 7.3

After Jonathan Harker attacks Dracula at his castle, the vampire travels to a nearby city, where he preys on the family of Harker's fiancée. The only one who may be able to protect them is Dr. van Helsing, Harker's friend and fellow-student of vampires, who is determined to destroy Dracula, whatever the cost.

details ↗
#12
The Defiant Ones poster

The Defiant Ones (1958)

🎬 Nominee⭐ Top-rated

Composite 68.54

Dir. Stanley Kramer · Tony Curtis · Sidney Poitier · Theodore Bikel · Charles McGraw

IMDb 7.5 (20,130 votes) · TMDB 7.1

Two convicts—one white, one black—escape while chained to each other.

details ↗
#13
Auntie Mame poster

Auntie Mame (1958)

🎬 Nominee⭐ Top-rated

Composite 68.39

Dir. Morton DaCosta · Rosalind Russell · Forrest Tucker · Coral Browne · Peggy Cass

IMDb 7.9 (13,855 votes) · TMDB 7.0

Mame Dennis, a progressive and independent woman of the 1920s, is left to care for her nephew Patrick after his wealthy father dies. Conflict ensues when the executor of the father's estate objects to the aunt's lifestyle and tries to force her to send Patrick to prep school.

details ↗
#14
The Magician poster

The Magician (1958)

⭐ Top-rated

Composite 68.27

Dir. Ingmar Bergman · Max von Sydow · Ingrid Thulin · Gunnar Björnstrand · Naima Wifstrand

IMDb 7.5 (11,897 votes) · TMDB 7.4

A traveling magician and his troupe arrive in a Swedish town in the 1840s, where their act is scrutinized by local authorities and a skeptical medical official. Their stay leads to a series of confrontations that test the boundaries between performance, belief, and deception.

details ↗
#15
The Fly poster

The Fly (1958)

⭐ Top-rated💰 Box office #10

Composite 67.66

Dir. Kurt Neumann · David Hedison · Patricia Owens · Vincent Price · Herbert Marshall

IMDb 7.1 (28,014 votes) · TMDB 7.04

Industrialist François Delambre is called late at night by his sister-in-law, Helene, who tells him that she has just killed her husband. Reluctant at first, she eventually explains to the police that he invented a matter transportation apparatus and, while experimenting on himself, a fly entered the chamber.

details ↗
#16
Separate Tables poster

Separate Tables (1958)

🎬 Nominee

Composite 66.29

Dir. Delbert Mann · Deborah Kerr · Rita Hayworth · David Niven · Wendy Hiller

IMDb 7.3 (9,830 votes) · TMDB 7.0

The lives of a disparate group of unfulfilled people converge at a small, seaside English hotel.

details ↗
#17
Bonjour Tristesse poster

Bonjour Tristesse (1958)

💰 Box office #4

Composite 64.1

Dir. Otto Preminger · Deborah Kerr · David Niven · Jean Seberg · Mylène Demongeot

IMDb 6.8 (6,377 votes) · TMDB 6.719

A spoiled teenager spends the summer at the French Riviera with her rich, widower, playboy father, but when his old flame resurfaces, she resolves to keep her frivolous lifestyle at all costs.

details ↗
#18
Gigi poster

Gigi (1958)

🏆 Winner💰 Box office #3

Composite 63.2

Dir. Vincente Minnelli · Leslie Caron · Maurice Chevalier · Louis Jourdan · Hermione Gingold

IMDb 6.6 (24,974 votes) · TMDB 6.2

A home, a motorcar, servants, the latest fashions: the most eligible and most finicky bachelor in Paris offers them all to Gigi. But she, who's gone from girlish gawkishness to cultured glamour before our eyes, yearns for that wonderful something money can't buy.

details ↗
#19
Houseboat poster

Houseboat (1958)

💰 Box office #9

Composite 63.15

Dir. Melville Shavelson · Cary Grant · Sophia Loren · Martha Hyer · Harry Guardino

IMDb 6.6 (10,527 votes) · TMDB 6.4

An Italian socialite on the run signs on as housekeeper for a widower with three children.

details ↗
#20
South Pacific poster

South Pacific (1958)

💰 Box office #1

Composite 62.87

Dir. Joshua Logan · Rossano Brazzi · Mitzi Gaynor · John Kerr · Ray Walston

IMDb 6.8 (11,045 votes) · TMDB 6.153

Can a girl from Little Rock find happiness with a mature French planter she got to know one enchanted evening away from the military hospital where she is a nurse? Or should she just wash that man out of her hair? Bloody Mary is the philosopher of the island and it's hard to believe she could be the mother of Liat who has captured the heart of Lt. Joseph Cable USMC. While waiting for action in the war in the South Pacific, sailors and nurses put on a musical comedy show. The war gets closer and the saga of Nellie Forbush and Emile de Becque becomes serious drama.

details ↗
#21
The Blob poster

The Blob (1958)

💰 Box office #6

Composite 62.29

Dir. Irvin S. Yeaworth Jr. · Steve McQueen · Aneta Corsaut · Earl Rowe · John Benson

IMDb 6.3 (32,315 votes) · TMDB 6.222

A drive-in favorite, this sci-fi classic follows teenagers Steve and his best girl, Jane, as they try to protect their hometown from a gelatinous alien life form that engulfs everything it touches. The first to discover the substance and live to tell about it, Steve and Jane witness the blob destroying an elderly man, then it growing to a terrifying size. But no one else has seen the goo, and policeman Dave refuses to believe the kids without proof.

details ↗

How scoring works: films are ranked by a composite of a weighted (Bayesian) IMDb rating — the same method as the IMDb Top 250, so a high score from few voters can't outrank a strong score from many — blended with TMDB. Box office is a tiebreaker and a badge, never part of the score. Raw IMDb ratings and vote counts are shown on each card.