One observes, with something approaching the satisfaction of a pattern confirmed, that no-hitters in Tolkien Baseball tend to arrive in pairs — as MESN noted when covering the Kapanaktsian and Rolán efforts earlier this season, the art of suppression, once demonstrated, appears reluctant to remain singular. Snuknogh Bugsmasher, starting pitcher for the Minas Morgul Slayers, has now added a third entry to the 2052 ledger.
On September 23rd, Bugsmasher retired the Grey Havens Stars across nine innings, allowing no hits and scattering three walks against 30 batters faced — the minimum contact with the base paths that a no-hitter will permit. Eleven strikeouts accompanied the effort. The Slayers won, 2-0, in what one might describe as an economical result: two runs, no defensive necessity whatsoever, and a pitcher who appeared, for the duration of the evening, to be solving a problem that had already been solved before he threw his first pitch.
The turning point, such as it was, arrived not in any single inning but in the aggregate — Bugsmasher's willingness to accept the walks (three, which is three more than a perfect game and three fewer than a problem) while denying the hit entirely. At 30 batters, the sample is not enormous, but it is internally consistent: not one Grey Havens batter found a way to put the ball in play safely, a circumstance that has befallen that franchise with some regularity this season. Irene Knotwise, who reached her 2,500th career hit playing for Grey Havens this year, was not, one notes, among those who extended her total tonight.
That Minas Morgul was simultaneously eliminated from playoff contention today — manager Mimosa Willow confirmed the mathematical conclusion in remarks reported elsewhere — gives the evening a particular texture. The Slayers will not play October baseball. Bugsmasher, at least, has given Morgul's remaining games a reason to be attended rather than merely endured.
This is the third no-hitter thrown in Tolkien Baseball's Troll Division in 2052. One had expected two. Three, it turns out, is what happened.

