Rivendell advances on Columbus Marblerage's decisive performance, ending Erebor's season in three.
The Rivendell Royals are through to the next round of the Tolkien Baseball postseason, having dispatched the Erebor Eagles 5-3 in a deciding Game 3 on October 8 at — one notes, not without appreciation for the symmetry — the same evening the Dagorlad Disaster were closing out their own Hobbit Series on the other side of the bracket. The Royals take the series 2-1.
Columbus Marblerage earned series MVP honors, and the hot-sheet data confirms the distinction was not ceremonial. Marblerage batted .500 across the series with a run driven in during the decisive contest — numbers that, over a three-game sample, begin to approach the threshold where one stops qualifying the sample size. Nisin Hagorsson complemented that effort with a .454 mark and two RBI on the Rivendell side, supplying the kind of consistent middle-of-the-order production that a short series demands and that the Eagles' pitching staff, having arrived here on a four-game losing streak, proved unable to contain.
Erebor was not without its moments. Zaghbub the Ugly batted .500 for the series, and both Carly Boffin and Eiamli Undomiel — who also reached 1,000 career hits during this season — posted .454 averages with multiple RBI. That three Eagle hitters were among the hottest bats in the league this week and the club still fell 5-3 speaks to where Rivendell's margin ultimately resided: not in suppressing Erebor's lineup wholesale, but in producing just enough ahead of it.
The Royals now advance carrying one notable absence. Gandaudur Tyriand, who entered this postseason one stolen base from the 100-career threshold, remains on the injured list with a strained Achilles tendon — a reminder that roster depth, not individual milestones, determines October outcomes. Gildor *Inglorion, whose pursuit of second place on the all-time wins list MESN has documented at some length, takes his 2-win deficit into the next round as well.
Rivendell faces what comes next. The Royals, at 91 wins during the regular season, have demonstrated sufficient quality to merit the position they now occupy. Whether that quality extends further is, as of this evening, an open question.

