Here's the thing about a "down year" for Ugak "Smokey" the Masher: it still tastes better than anyone else's full Sunday roast.
The Dead Marshes shortstop has won his seventh Aragorn Award, announced Wednesday, November 19th, and the most remarkable aspect of the announcement is the general consensus — among writers, managers, and apparently the Masher himself — that 2052 represented something of a cold stretch. The man hit .350. Best average in the league. He posted 43 home runs, 106 RBI, 113 runs scored, 100 walks against only 54 strikeouts, and 39 stolen bases — one short, mind you, of a 40/40 season, which itself would have been the garnish on a meal most hitters would frame and hang above the fireplace. And the conversation around the Dead Marshes dugout, apparently, is that the Masher could have done more.
I'll say this much: if that's cold mutton, somebody needs to recalibrate their pantry.
Seven Aragorn Awards. The 27-year-old switch-hitting shortstop now has seven of them, and the award is not being given out charitably. The Masher earned his Sam Gamgee Batter award for the Mordor Conference on the same day, backing up the Aragorn with full accounting of what .350 actually looks like in practice: 188 hits, 39 doubles, 2 triples, 43 home runs, 113 runs, 106 RBI. Those are not the numbers of a player in decline. Those are the numbers of a player who has — somewhere along the way — set his personal expectations so high that a 10-win season reads like a shrug and a trip to the icebox for leftovers.
The rest of the Tolkien awards came due on the same Wednesday, and the Mordor Conference had its own full table of honorees. Hyeon-cheong Alejadre of the Dagorlad Disaster claims the MC Gandalf Pitcher Award on the back of an 18-6 record, 33 starts, and 255 strikeouts. Andwise Holeman, the Dagorlad third baseman, wins the Frodo Rookie Award: .249, 126 hits, 17 home runs, 53 RBI in 146 games. Sméagol Stonemould of the Minas Morgul Slayers takes the MC relief award, a calming presence out of the bullpen that belied his 25 years considerably.
Over in the Shire Conference, Belegond Lucier's Triple Crown season earned him the Shire Aragorn — as MESN covered separately in some detail, and which still has me reaching for a second cup of tea when I think about it.
Seven, though. Seven Aragorn Awards. The Masher remains, in a down year, the best hitter in Tolkien Baseball. Somebody tell the Dead Marshes to be very, very patient with him.

