Rhedry "Bloodstained" Scimitar arrived at the Glass Tower this spring with the same thing he brings every spring: a coffee thermos the size of a dwarf's boot, 13 seasons of stories about right field in Minas Tirith, and the unshakeable conviction that the color commentator's chair belongs to him.

Then Bingo Banks walked in.

Banks spent most of his playing career in Erebor — a few detours through Dunharrow, Lake Town, and Minas Tirith — before his ankle ended the whole enterprise after 2052. He is polite, prepared, and laughs at his own mistakes on the air, which is not something Scimitar has ever been observed doing. His first season in the booth has gone well enough that people are noticing, and the people Scimitar most minds noticing are the ones upstairs in the Glass Tower.

"He's a gamer," said Brandt Goldmane, which tells you nothing except that Brandt Goldmane was in the room.

The tension surfaces in small ways. Scimitar arrives to production meetings first, every time, and positions himself at the head of the table before Banks can get near it. Banks once offered to handle the third-inning breakdown on a complicated bunt call; Scimitar explained, at considerable length, that he had seen a bunt in Minas Tirith in 2011 that made this one look "quaint." Banks nodded and wrote something on his notepad. Nobody knows what.

What Banks has that Scimitar does not, and everyone on two floors knows it, is freshness. He finished playing the game eight months ago. The seams on a curveball are not yet metaphor to him; they are still memory. When he describes the way a slider looks breaking out of a left-hander's hand, it carries the weight of recent experience rather than twenty years of booth amber. That is not a small thing.

Scimitar's Hall of Fame plaque — Minas Tirith Titans, 2007 through 2019, then ten more with the Darkwings — is not going anywhere. Neither is the institutional loyalty he's accumulated over two decades in the booth. Legend has it that Dex Farrow once floated a format change that would have trimmed Scimitar's innings per broadcast; the idea did not survive the coffee-pot situation between Radio and the Gazette, nor, rumor holds, Scimitar's thirty-minute visit to Hepzibah Thrum's office.

But institutional loyalty has a shelf life. Banks is not pushing. He shows up, does the work, and lets the tape make the argument.

That, more than anything, is what Scimitar keeps watching.