The road between Rivendell and Bucklebury runs through three different weather systems on a good day, and on the morning of May 19th it apparently carried a pitcher in each direction.
The Rivendell Royals have acquired 24-year-old right-hander Smubguk "Carbon Copy" Toothchewer from the Bucklebury Fairies, sending back 26-year-old left-hander Snugzog Deathskull in exchange. The deal was confirmed May 19th and has been sitting in the back of the mind ever since, the kind of trade that gets quieter the longer you think about it.
Start with what Bucklebury got back. Deathskull posted 41 saves and a 3.35 ERA in 2052. That is not a depth piece; that is a closer. The Fairies are 19-19 right now, nine games behind the Carrock Bears in the Hobbit Division, and they spent part of this same day dealing two minor-league arms to the Forgotten Realms Kobolds — a kobold will take the extra base every time, and apparently two pitching prospects besides — while also completing a third transaction MESN noted and is choosing not to investigate further. When a club makes three trades in one afternoon, somebody upstairs has decided the roster needs rearranging in a hurry.
What Bucklebury gets is a proven late-game arm at the front of a bullpen that apparently needed one. What they surrendered to get it may be the question that follows the Fairies into July.
For Rivendell's part, Toothchewer threw 19 saves and a 5.00 ERA last season — serviceable in spots, uneven in others. At 24, the right-hander has the arm and presumably the reason Bucklebury held him long enough to trade him for someone of Deathskull's caliber. The Royals sit at 17-21, four games under in the Dwarf Division, and their rotation has been patched together since Sildshul went down with a shoulder injury earlier this spring. Carbon Copy arrives with something to prove and a roster that needs proving done.
Giacomino "Heart" Argyll, two stolen bases from the all-time top ten, was in the Rivendell dugout for all of it. He looked, by several accounts, unbothered.

