2053 PRESEASON PREVIEW · PART 7 OF 7

The 2053 Closer: The Titans, a 38-Year-Old Catcher, and a Monkey That Has Not Reconsidered Bywater

mesn-preseason-desk · 2026-10-29

State of the League

The Shire's Aragorn MVP ballot this spring goes to a 38-year-old catcher whose team lost 98 games. DeForest *Hamrh hit .298 with 14 home runs and 5.2 WAR in 110 games for the Mirkwood Sylvan last season. He enters 2053 twenty-one homers shy of 400, and his award history runs back to 2031. Mirkwood went 64-98 around him. The other headline is the Carrock Bears, who open as defending champions under a first-year manager, Eeamir Elvalas. This desk does not pick them to win their own division.

The Shire is the stronger conference. It is deeper through the middle and holds the best roster in the league in Minas Tirith. Mordor is flatter: Dol Guldur and Ravenhill stand nearly level at the top, and the Troll Division may go to a club that finished under .500.

Old Forest made the deepest cuts. Tom Bombadil, in his 41st season in the dugout, watched payroll fall from $234.1 million, the largest in the league, to $98.8 million, which ranks fourteenth. The Merry Fellows still won the Elf at 92-70 last year, and they kept dealing this spring. Left fielder Teryani Ipyllasc and right-hander Xu-gang Sharmistha both went to Dagorlad for younger pitching. The goblins' annual coin landed heads, the side reserved for money. Old Forest's ledger then went down a row of three goblins, each of whom weighed it in one palm and handed it back.

Then there is the clock. Negussu Horse-lover of Minas Ithil is one hit from 1,500. Bucca Brownlock of Lothlorien is two home runs from 300. Till "Blueprint" Underhill is 43 and remains Isengard's highest-paid player at $9.7 million, as a reliever.

Playoff Field and Title Pick

In the Shire, Minas Tirith wins the Elf, Bywater takes the Hobbit and Erebor claims the Dwarf. Carrock and Old Forest take the wild cards. Mirkwood finishes one step outside the field, Hamrh notwithstanding.

The Titans went 82-80 last year, missed the playoffs, then cut $54 million in payroll. That is not the usual road to a pennant. The case for them is what remains. Mirabella Sandybanks, Gandaudur Tyriand and Thuror Elril-Gara head the contract list. Bruno Holgate hit 15 home runs in 77 games last year. And Cedrick Elesserio's seven years in charge are the longest tenure in the Shire after Tom Bombadil's forty-one.

In Mordor, Dol Guldur wins the Orc and the conference. The Dragons have Vrsong the Drooler, the league's highest-rated manager, and a payroll that rose $16.1 million while most of the league's fell. Ravenhill takes the Goblin a year after going 74-88. Dead Marshes wins the Troll under Mikee the German, now in his 21st season. Dagorlad and Dunharrow claim the wild cards. The monkey had Ravenhill second in the Goblin last spring, and they finished fourth. Shown the same board this March, it slapped the Ravenhill logo with an open palm and held it there for a count of six.

MESN's title pick is Minas Tirith over Dol Guldur. OOTP, after its spring re-run, projects the Titans at 78-84 and third in their own division, with Old Forest winning 98 games. The two projections are twenty wins and a pennant apart.

Award Picks

Shire. Hamrh takes both the Shire Aragorn and the Shire Sam Gamgee. The case for him is that he hit .298 at 37 while catching, and that his 5.2 WAR in 110 games scales well past that over a full season. The case against is twelve career seasons with time on the injured list, plus a lineup that will not put many runners on ahead of him. OOTP prefers Old Forest's Alrond "Supremacy" *Hubbard, Jr., who hit .302 with 37 homers and 95 steals last season. Hubbard is the Shire dark horse. The Phrenologist's Bumps Chart measured Hamrh's cranium and noted "exceptionally favorable" bump distribution in the relevant region. The relevant region has not been disclosed to this desk.

Mordor. Romochka Carnicas takes both the Mordor Aragorn and the Mordor Sam Gamgee. He is a 34-year-old shortstop and the highest-paid player at $30.5 million on a Dagorlad club that won 90 games and carries the league's second-largest payroll. The obvious objection is Ugak "Smokey" *the Masher of Dead Marshes. Smokey hit .350 with 43 home runs, 100 walks and 11.2 WAR last year, and OOTP projects him as Mordor's top hitter. He is the Mordor dark horse in roughly the way a mountain is a dark horse to a hill. The pick is still the shortstop.

The rest of the ballot:

Breakouts

Hyeon-cheong Alejadre, Dagorlad. He went 18-6 with a 2.29 ERA, 255 strikeouts in 220.1 innings and 8.3 WAR, at 22. OOTP already projects him as Mordor's best pitcher, so the only breakout left is the trophy. He takes the Mordor Gandalf from Ibpug the Badger if Dagorlad's defense holds.

Belegond Lucier, Old Forest. The third baseman hit .338 with 48 home runs, 123 RBI and 206 hits, worth 9.2 WAR. He is 26 and plays every day for a team that just shed its payroll but not him. He is the likeliest hitter to take the Shire Sam Gamgee away from Hamrh.

Suzg Holzer, Carrock. He saved 21 games with a 0.74 ERA over 36.2 innings. The catch is 525 career days on the injured list across seven seasons. The jump is a health question, not a stuff question, and if he reaches 60 innings he wins the Shire Gwaihir.

Thuus "Homicide" Yraueme, Grey Havens. He posted a 1.80 ERA with 53 strikeouts and seven walks in 35 innings, at 21. Grey Havens has the weakest roster in Mordor and no reason to save him for anything. He is closing by June and enters the Mordor Gwaihir conversation by August.

Bold Predictions

Bywater wins the Hobbit. A new skipper in Sulak Daggerdrinker, a rebuilt left side of the infield and Cormyth at the front of the rotation make up for last year's 74-88. OOTP has them fourth at 73-89. The monkey had them first last spring as well. This year it carried the Bywater logo to the corner of its enclosure and sat with it through lunch.

Erebor wins the Dwarf. The Eagles made the playoffs from third place at 88-74 and added Shivaji "Gambler" Brown from the SFL's Babylon Five Rangers. OOTP has them fourth.

Minas Ithil, defending Dwarf champion at 94-68, finishes third. The Wyrms added $18.8 million in payroll and a first-year manager, Gomsh Elephantdicer. OOTP picks them first.

Dunharrow finishes second in the Orc, one year after losing 100 games. The 3.87 staff ERA was never the problem. Rapu Vale and Misagenes Foebinder, paid a combined $61.4 million, are owed better luck than 62-100.

What Changed During the Series

The spring brought the following moves:

OOTP re-ran its projections after spring training and changed its mind in four divisions:

On awards, OOTP's projected top Shire pitcher moved from Gaetano Sowell to Frugorn Coronda. Its top Shire hitter, and with him its Aragorn favorite, moved from Faramir Bridger to Hubbard. Bywater is the only team OOTP has now picked both first and fourth in the same spring.

The Monkey's 2052 Reckoning

Last spring the monkey named two division winners correctly: Old Forest in the Elf and Lothlorien in the Goblin. It also nailed Numenor's third and Grey Havens' fourth. In four of the six divisions, the eventual winner was the team it had placed second. Carrock won the Hobbit and the title from that slot, while the monkey's choice for first, Bywater, finished third at 74-88. Minas Ithil, Dol Guldur and Weathertop also won from second, behind Rivendell, Isengard and Minas Morgul.

The 2053 board shows what it took from this. Both correct winners are gone from the top line. Old Forest drops to second in the Elf, and Lothlorien falls to fourth in the Goblin. Isengard, last year's Orc pick, is fourth. Ravenhill, picked second and finished fourth, is promoted to first. And Bywater is first again. The monkey has abandoned everything it got right and doubled down on its most expensive mistake. Handlers placed the 2052 standings beside its board on Monday, and it ate the corner of the page.

Elsewhere in the SGCBL

The SciFi and Fantasy League opens April 21. Narnia is the defending champion after a league-best 77-49 run. Karak Kadrin (74-52), New New York (73-53) and Babylon Five (68-58) also won their divisions. WeMadeIt went 71-55 and missed the playoffs anyway, then made the winter's biggest push. The Crashlanders traded for 3B Elrauwyn Vardamir, 29, who hit .273 with 22 home runs and 6.3 WAR. They also added LF Semolina Wisebattler, 30, a .297 hitter, and sent out LF Teryani Ipyllasc, 27, who was worth 3.5 WAR. The Babylon Five Rangers traded LF Shivaji Brown, 35, coming off a .273, 20-homer, 3.5-WAR season. The Diagon Alley Wizards, 49-77 last year, signed CF Kamer Evensta, 31, as a free agent after he hit .234 with 14 homers.

The Middle Earth Independent League opens April 8. The Imlad Morgul Night Hawks are the defending champions at 81-63. Lond Daer had the best record at 88-56, with Belegost close behind at 86-58. Edoras reached the playoffs at 70-75. The Night Hawks lost LF Chin-seok Revolorio, 31, a .285 hitter, to free agency. The Cirith Ninniach 89ers traded Vardamir to the SFL and took on Briblag the Mangler from Bywater. The Tirion Navigators lost 1B Ezerhan Polarian, 33, and his 20 home runs to free agency. RF Eriladar Aelorothi, 23, left the Nurn Blue Jays and signed with the Rhun Wheat Kings despite hitting .220 with -1.1 WAR.