So, maybe it wasn’t the best of the trilogy, but the 11 Oscars for Return of the King weren’t so much about that specific movie as a nod to the incredible effort (and amazing faith) it took to even attempt to put Tolkien’s work on film. To have it not suck was my small prayer back in 1999 when I first heard about it. To have it be so brilliant exceeded my greatest hopes. It was a wonderful night of awards for a wonderful group of people.
In fact, I cannot remember ever watching the Oscars without disagreeing with at least one choice. That’s the whole reason the Lunch Gang™ came up with the idea for the Oscar Do-Overs. But I can’t think of any choice I’d argue with this year.